Church History

Our History

Bethlehem Missionary Baptist Church – Established 1911

Founded in 1911, Bethlehem Missionary Baptist Church has been a steadfast pillar of faith and community in Brunswick County for over a century. Though some of the earliest written records have been lost to time, we are grateful for the oral histories preserved by our faithful elder members. We especially honor the late Mother Pearl Lofton Williams (1905–2004), who witnessed the church’s birth and remained a devoted member until her passing at the age of 99. We also thank the late Deacon James Augustus Jinwright, Mother Gerthel Pridgen, and Sister Vivian Denkins McRae for their invaluable historical contributions.

Humble Beginnings

Bethlehem’s story began in the rural Lee Buck area, born from the prayers and vision of a small group of faithful believers who desired a place to worship. By the grace of God and the generosity of a man named Dan Ward, land was donated for this purpose. Early worship services were held beneath the sheltering branches of towering oak trees. Mother Pearl recounted how members would wade through high water after rainstorms to gather for worship—undaunted and full of faith.

Eventually, the congregation erected a wooden building, which served as their sanctuary until 1951, when a cinder block church was constructed. While the church building improved, the road leading to it remained unpaved and difficult to travel. Yet, the spirit and determination of the members remained strong.

A Legacy of Leadership

Through the years, Bethlehem was shepherded by several dedicated pastors, including:

Rev. Willie Johnson
Rev. Sheppard Newkirk
Rev. Joseph Williams
Rev. Castela Goodman
Rev. Willie Perkins Yeoman (1946–1975)

Under Rev. Yeoman’s passionate leadership, Bethlehem grew spiritually, physically, and financially. His vision led to numerous improvements, including the purchase of a church bus in 1961 and a vote to relocate the church to higher ground in 1967.

In 1970, the church moved to its current location at 9374 Southern Blvd SE in Winnabow, NC. A new building was constructed with the help of Blake Builders for $15,000. On October 18, 1970, Rev. Yeoman led the congregation in a symbolic march to the new sanctuary. During the building process, he humbly gave up his salary to support the church’s financial needs.

Pastoral Transitions and Growth

After Rev. Yeoman’s resignation due to illness in 1975, Bethlehem was led by:

Rev. Otis Ervin Pelham (1975–1983)
Rev. Dr. Andre Carr, Sr. (1984–2007)
Rev. Eric A. Joyner, Sr. (2007-2010)
Rev. Rodney Gore (2011-2013)
Rev. Latonio Thomas (2014-2016)
Rev. David L. Smith (2017–Present)

Each pastor brought unique gifts that helped Bethlehem grow in faith and service. Under Rev. Dr. Carr’s leadership, over 150 souls joined the church, and a new wave of physical improvements took place.

Music, Education, and Ministry

Bethlehem has been blessed with faithful servants throughout its history. On September 16, 1961, Sister Vivian Denkins McRae was elected pianist and served for 57 consecutive years. Our Christian Education ministry continues to thrive under the leadership of Reverend Edith Blanks (Superintendent).

We also honor the many Deacons who have served faithfully throughout the decades, helping to support the spiritual and operational needs of the church.

A New Chapter: Rev. David L. Smith

In 2017, Rev. David L. Smith, along with First Lady Natalie B. Smith, answered the call to lead Bethlehem. He officially began his pastoral journey with us on November 26, 2017. On August 25, 2018, the membership unanimously voted to install Rev. Smith as Pastor. The installation service, scheduled for September 16, 2018, was delayed due to the devastating impact of Hurricane Florence.

Despite the physical damage caused by the storm—including a toppled steeple and sanctuary flooding—Rev. Smith remained steadfast. His focus has never been on ceremony, but on the spiritual growth and restoration of God’s house and people. His preaching, teaching, and compassionate leadership continue to uplift and inspire our congregation.

Continuing the Legacy

From outdoor worship under oak trees to a thriving church family, Bethlehem Missionary Baptist Church stands as a testimony to God’s faithfulness and the perseverance of His people. While it’s impossible to name every individual who contributed to our growth, we thank God for each member, past and present, who has labored in love and service.

To God be the glory for the things He has done—and is still doing—at Bethlehem.